Selection & Admission Appeals

If you have been denied entry into a course there are steps you can take to dispute the decision.

What’s this page for?

Missing out on a place in a course can be disappointing, especially when you’ve worked so hard to get to this point. Once the University has finalised its selection in any given intake, it can be challenging to have this decision changed. There are steps you can take to have the outcome reviewed, though you should know that the avenues available are limited.

Under the University’s Selections and Admissions Policy, prospective students potentially have two (sequential) avenues of appeal for a selection decision. This can be seen in the below flowchart.

This page will take you through each of these steps and explain what you need to know about both processes.

FAQs

Understanding the selection process

Where can I find the minimum entry requirements for the course I want to apply for?

Before you apply for a course you should understand the minimum entry requirements. Minimum entry requirements for consideration for selection including the University’s English language requirements are published in the Handbook.

It's important to understand that even if you meet the minimum entry requirements this does not automatically guarantee you will be offered a place in the course. Selection is a competitive process!

For example, if there are 50 places available for a course, and 150 prospective students who have applied for the course, then those 150 prospective students will be ranked according to their WAM and any other selection criteria, with the first 50 applicants being given an offer.

What is considered by a selection committee?

The University has published Resolutions on Selection guidelines on their website. This can help to inform you of the standards the selection committee considers for your particular degree.

I want to apply for a course, but I have special circumstances that I would like considered as part of my application, can that be done?

Yes, if you are applying for an undergraduate course you can apply through Access Melbourne, where a range of circumstances are taken into consideration as part of the selection process. Eligibility requirements apply.

If you are applying for a graduate degree you can apply through Graduate Access Melbourne. Only some courses allow for graduate access applications.

I don’t think I meet the minimum entry requirements for the course I want to apply for, what can I do?

There may be alternative study pathways available to get into the course you want. The best thing to do is get course advice to understand what options may be available, and what is needed to gain entry in future. You can speak to an advisor at Stop 1.

Please be aware that the Advocacy Service cannot provide course advice.

What is the University's policy on selection and admission?

The University's Selection and Admission Policy provides a framework to ensure the integrity of selection and admission decisions, outlines the responsibilities of decision makers and promotes transparency, consistency, and fairness throughout the process.

Requesting a review of the decision

I’ve just found out I didn’t get into my course – what can I do?

The very first step is to find out the reasons for the decision. In order to do this, an applicant should contact the relevant selection staff to understand the selection process, and how their application was determined.

How can I contact the relevant selection staff?

In order to streamline this process, the University has developed an online form that allows you to request feedback on your application. You can access the form here.

I understand why my application was rejected, but I want to have the decision reviewed. How can I do that?

Once you have received feedback about your application, and why it was not successful, contact us for advice on whether there is basis to dispute the decision. Where there is a basis to pursue the dispute, the next step is to request a formal review of the decision. You can use the same form as above to do request a review.

Your request for a review is sent to the Academic Registrar via the online form, however in most cases a response is delegated to the Associate Director of Admissions, so it is likely you’ll receive a reply from them.

To request a formal review, you will need to set out the basis of your concerns. You should expect a formal response in a reasonable time, allowing for the conduct of a formal investigation. The response to this review should clearly set out the decision and its basis.

I’m a postgraduate study applicant, is the review process the same for me?

Yes, you need to complete the same online form to request a review of the decision. However, before you do this you need to check the University’s postgraduate study eligibility calculator and use this as a guide. You will need to include a screenshot of the calculator response as part of your review request.

If you remain unhappy with the outcome of the review, please contact us, and include all copies of this previous correspondence, so we can advise on the prospects of progressing the matter to an Academic Board Appeal.

Appealing the decision

What steps should I follow to appeal the decision?

Step 1: Review the appeals information on our Academic Board Appeal website.

Step 2: Contact us for advice. You will need to send us:

  • The reasons for the decision
  • The outcome from your review
  • Any other correspondence you have had with the University about this decision

Step 3: The final step is to lodge an appeal with the Academic Board.

The Academic Board can only consider an appeal if it directly addresses the grounds available under s 4.4 of the Student Appeals Policy, which for Selection Appeals is limited to:

4.4. An appeal made under 4.2(h) can only be made on the grounds that a procedural irregularity has occurred in the selection process.

This differs from other appeals where the full range of grounds are available.

For this reason Selection Appeals can be difficult to pursue, so if you remain dissatisfied with a decision following a review, it is best to contact us for advice.

When contacting us ensure you include all copies of the previous correspondence you have had about this decision, so we can advise on the prospects of progressing the matter to an Academic Board Appeal.